Forward
Charlie Sharp
Position: F
Height: 6’4
Weight: 185
DOB: 6/23/01
Hometown: Brighton, Mich.
Acquired: 12/2/25
Previous club: Toronto FC (MLS)
Indy Eleven signed former Toronto FC forward Charlie Sharp on December 2, 2025.
The 24-year-old striker inked a contract with Major League Soccer’s Toronto FC in September of 2024 after registering five goals and two assists in 16 games for Toronto FC II in MLS NEXT Pro. Since then, Sharp notched one assist in eight appearances for Toronto in MLS.
In 2025, Sharp made his first career MLS start vs. NYCFC on Apr. 26, recording two shots in 88 minutes. He registered his first assist vs. Nashville SC on May 24, finishing the campaign with two key passes and 12 aerial duals in six matches.
The 6’4, 185-pound Sharp was loaned to the Tampa Bay Rowdies in August, playing in eight games with two starts, five shots, and three fouls won.
The Brighton, Michigan, native played college soccer close to home at Western Michigan. Sharp was drafted by Toronto in the third round of the 2023 MLS SuperDraft but elected to remain at WMU for his final year. In 2023, Sharp led NCAA Division I with 19 goals (including seven game winners) in 20 matches, adding eight assists, and helping his team to the NCAA Sweet 16.
His record-breaking season led to him becoming WMU’s first-ever finalist for the 2023 MAC Hermann Trophy, the most-coveted individual honor in NCAA Division I soccer. The All-American and Academic All-American finished his career at WMU with a school-record 43 goals (15 game winners) and 25 assists in 90 appearances.
